What you will learn
A sound VAT review connects the client setup, source transactions, return figures and review evidence. Work through a small period, then see why an invoice total and a cash-basis VAT figure can differ.
By the end, you can
- Check the scope and scheme before reviewing return figures.
- Trace a return total to source evidence.
- Distinguish a return liability, control balance and payment.
- Keep a clear approved version and submission record.
Before you begin
- Work through the supplied figures on paper.
- Know the difference between standard and cash VAT timing.
- Before applying the method to a client, confirm the VAT scheme, period and source records.
1. Set the scope before the numbers
Confirm the legal entity, VAT registration details, scheme and return period before reviewing transactions. Record the exact start and end dates. A familiar quarter name is not a substitute for the selected obligation.
This exercise uses ordinary domestic transactions with their VAT treatment already agreed. It does not cover partial exemption, reverse charge, imports, Flat Rate Scheme calculations or adjustments. Those need their own review. Use VAT setup help to check the client configuration.
HMRC's VAT return guidance explains the return boxes and timing rules. Use current official guidance when deciding the treatment of a real transaction.
2. Review a simple return
Fictional Beacon Services has eligible sales VAT of £400 and recoverable purchase VAT of £150 for this period. Box 2 is zero. All supporting documents have been checked and there are no other adjustments.
| Return figure | Expected amount |
|---|---|
| Box 1: VAT due on sales | £400 |
| Box 2 | £0 |
| Box 3: total VAT due | £400 |
| Box 4: VAT reclaimed | £150 |
| Box 5: amount payable | £250 |
Start with the transaction breakdown behind a figure. Check dates, VAT codes, source evidence and reviewed amounts. Review the net-value boxes separately; they are not proved merely because Box 5 agrees.
Try this. Calculate the VAT payable in the simple return. Then explain how the separate part-payment example changes the timing under cash accounting.
3. Understand why payment timing matters
Consider a separate example under the Cash Accounting Scheme. An invoice has net £1,000, VAT £200 and gross £1,200. A £600 qualifying bank transfer settles half of that invoice in the period. In this simple example, £100 of the invoice VAT follows that payment, subject to the scheme's rules.
The unpaid £600 remains a customer amount. It is not missing merely because its associated VAT is outside the current cash-basis calculation. Follow the settlement back to the invoice and confirm that the correct amount was allocated.
HMRC's Cash Accounting Scheme guidance explains receipt and payment timing, part payments and exceptions. Do not apply this example to every VAT scheme or assume that every statement date determines the tax period.
4. Explain the VAT control account
The return shows the liability or repayment for one VAT period. A control account can also contain opening VAT, earlier return settlements and transactions outside that return's scope. Compare the two using a movement schedule rather than forcing them to be identical.
Suppose Beacon brought forward £300 payable for an earlier return and paid that £300 during this period. Add the current £250 liability. The closing amount payable is £250, assuming no other movements. Retain the earlier payment reference and period so the reviewer can reproduce the reconciliation.
Use VAT settlements and opening balances help for the product workflow. Resolve a difference at its source before concluding that a journal is required.
5. Preserve the version being approved
Complete the review of included transactions, adjustments and exceptions before sharing the return for approval. Make it clear which entity and period the approval concerns. If figures change after review, check the revised version through the appropriate approval workflow.
After submission, retain the submitted figures and the resulting receipt or status. A prepared return, an approved return and a successfully submitted return are different stages. Check the outcome rather than relying on the fact that a send action was attempted.
The payment of £250 is a separate settlement task. Record it against the VAT liability using the relevant period and reference. Follow VAT returns help for the submission steps.
Model answer and completion evidence
Model answer: Beacon's current return is £250 payable because Box 3 is £400 and Box 4 is £150. The separate cash-accounting example recognises £100 of VAT against the qualifying £600 part payment. These examples use different stated assumptions and should not be combined.
Your review pack should let another person find the setup, transaction totals, explanation of control movements, approved version and submission outcome. A concise period note should identify any judgement referred to the VAT reviewer, together with its supporting document.
Check your understanding
Read the answer and explanation
£250.
The exercise gives a £250 liability. Earlier return payments and opening control balances need their own reconciliation.
Optional: selecting this button saves only this lesson’s completion on this browser. It does not create a Balansix training record or certificate, and it will not follow you to another device.